Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Phil Steele's messed-up All-WAC team



Phil Steele, one of the more famous names related of college football preview magazines, has released his picks for the WAC's all-conference teams. And boy did he pick some doozies.

First, allow us to disagree with a number of items:

  • Kyle Brotzman: 4th team kicker
  • First team defense: no Broncos
  • Second through fourth team offense: no Broncos
  • No Jeron Johnson
  • No Titus Young
  • No Vinny Perretta
  • No Richie Brockel
At least Steele found Ian Johnson's name while he was figuring, in vain, the distance between his rear end and a hole in the ground. In all, Boise State had three first team members (Andrew Woodruff and Jeremy Childs joined Johnson with that distinction), and one second team member. That is exactly one more than Utah State and two less than Idaho.


In addition to egregious mistakes on the Bronco front, we had some nits to pick with the rest of Steele's reality-challenged opus. But the greatest one might have been the horrible future he predicted when he named NMSU QB Chase Holbrook to the first team.

Needless to say, we will not be purchasing Steele's print publication.

Phil Steele's 2008 WAC all-conference [Philsteele.com]

4 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If you placed Dominic and Colin on the first team and put those other guys on the second team, then the first team offense would be correct (or close to it) from what I see.

    PWtW will have thoughts on these "preview" magazines as well because there are some glaring misprints.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Steele has JC transfers or guys that have never played a down on his 1st and 2nd teams. You can't make rankings based on "potential".

    ReplyDelete
  4. I do not get Phil Steele. I think a dart and dartboard could have come up with the same teams.

    (As an aside, I really like "PWtW"; if only it was phonetic!)

    ReplyDelete